Court Sides With California Card Rooms on Blackjack
HighlightsÂ
-
California card rooms score a legal win over blackjack and player-dealer rules.Â
-
Kyle Kirkland, California Gaming Association President, expressed relief over the decision.
A California court handed card rooms a major legal win on Tuesday, ruling that the Bureau of Gambling Control had overstepped its authority by enforcing two wide-ranging regulatory changes effective from 1 April.
Judge Richard Darwin of the San Francisco Superior Court affirmed the preliminary injunction issued in May, which halted enforcement of the regulations while the dispute was being heard.Â
Darwin made clear at the earlier hearing and repeated on Tuesday that the state had an uphill battle to change his view, and it ultimately failed to do so.
The current context and the concerns addressed are the new regulations for blackjack-style games and the use of player-dealers. This could have hurt card room revenue and tax generation. The BGC is one of two gaming regulatory bodies in California, along with the state’s Gambling Control Commission.
The commission serves as the independent regulator responsible for day-to-day oversight, whereas the BGC, part of the Attorney General’s Office, focuses primarily on enforcement matters.Â
Card rooms argued that the BGC exceeded its statutory role by introducing the rule changes, a position that Judge Darwin endorsed. The new regulations would have forced card rooms to overhaul blackjack-style games by removing the “bust” feature.Â
These measures also required player-dealers to rotate every 40 minutes and mandated that the dealer position be offered to all players before every hand.
Total revenue from both blackjack-style and live dealer games amounts to $5 billion as of 2019. The state estimated that the regulations could reduce card rooms’ blackjack revenue by approximately 50%.Â
Several operators warned that the changes could force closures, while host cities rushed to consider fiscal measures, including sales tax increases, to help offset the anticipated losses.
After the hearing, Kyle Kirkland, president of the California Gaming Association and owner of Club One Casino in Fresno, said that the ruling confirmed the legitimacy of the card rooms’ position and personally felt relieved by this move.
To know the full news story, Read Here!
Judge Richard Darwin of the San Francisco Superior Court affirmed the preliminary injunction issued in May, which halted enforcement of the regulations while the dispute was being heard.Â
Darwin made clear at the earlier hearing and repeated on Tuesday that the state had an uphill battle to change his view, and it ultimately failed to do so.
The current context and the concerns addressed are the new regulations for blackjack-style games and the use of player-dealers. This could have hurt card room revenue and tax generation. The BGC is one of two gaming regulatory bodies in California, along with the state’s Gambling Control Commission.
The commission serves as the independent regulator responsible for day-to-day oversight, whereas the BGC, part of the Attorney General’s Office, focuses primarily on enforcement matters.Â
Card rooms argued that the BGC exceeded its statutory role by introducing the rule changes, a position that Judge Darwin endorsed. The new regulations would have forced card rooms to overhaul blackjack-style games by removing the “bust” feature.Â
These measures also required player-dealers to rotate every 40 minutes and mandated that the dealer position be offered to all players before every hand.
Total revenue from both blackjack-style and live dealer games amounts to $5 billion as of 2019. The state estimated that the regulations could reduce card rooms’ blackjack revenue by approximately 50%.Â
Several operators warned that the changes could force closures, while host cities rushed to consider fiscal measures, including sales tax increases, to help offset the anticipated losses.
After the hearing, Kyle Kirkland, president of the California Gaming Association and owner of Club One Casino in Fresno, said that the ruling confirmed the legitimacy of the card rooms’ position and personally felt relieved by this move.
To know the full news story, Read Here!
